This is BS for the reason I state in this article's comments:Testimony from people who actually have kids is, of course, going to be more credible. (See Roald Dahl's story about his daughter for a particularly affecting testimony.) I'd urge parents with the impulse to shame and insult to try that approach instead, not just because it strikes me as more likely to persuade the typical anti-vaccine parent, but due to the conviction that while anti-vaxer ignorance has caused great damage, the vast majority are not, in fact, especially selfish people, and characterizing them as such just feeds into their mistaken belief system. Put another way, the parents I know who vaccinated their children, mine included, were not acting selflessly or sacrificially to protect the herd. They were appropriately confident that vaccinating their kids would significantly increase rather than reduce their chances of surviving and thriving in this world.Well-informed selfish people get vaccinated!
"Anti-vaxers should not be pandered to..." Which is why we should not legitimize their willful ignorance by framing the issue as if it were a debate. See if parents don't care that they are causing "great damage" to other people, the yes they are selfish, ESPECIALLY when they have the knowledge and opportunity to do otherwise. This is stuff we learned in 1st grade, yet a segment of us have to act like we didn't. We SHOULD be ashamed of such ignorance, if we are the functioning, capable, civilized society we THINK we are!I mean, geez just because unvaccinated people help spread diseases when they don't have to doesn't mean that they should bad about it or anything. Health concerns should be treated as if they were a customer service issue by which foolishness should be given the benefit of the doubt, right? Maybe we should start offering a free toaster with every vaccination, so the anti-vaxxers can be "persuaded" not infect an alarming group of people. If it produces one less hand-wringing article about whether the public is acquiescent enough toward myths and ignorance, so much the better.